TL;DR
Get movie nights delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Guillermo Rodriguez and professional partner Witney Carson were eliminated from Dancing with the Stars after the show’s Super Bowl-themed Week 5 episode. On Jimmy Kimmel Live, Jimmy Kimmel cited online video views while discussing the result. The reported details do not explain how votes were counted or establish that voting was flawed.
Guillermo Rodriguez and Witney Carson were eliminated from Dancing with the Stars after Tuesday’s Super Bowl-themed episode. On Jimmy Kimmel Live, Jimmy Kimmel discussed the result, citing the pair’s online video views and judges’ score. The information reported so far does not show how the final vote was calculated.
On his show, Kimmel said Rodriguez and Carson had made it to Week 5 and had become popular online. He displayed figures showing their previous week’s YouTube videos had 719,000 views, compared with 231,000 for Harry Shum Jr. and Jenna Johnson, whom he described as the next-closest pair. Those view totals measure video views, however, and do not establish how many viewers voted or how votes were distributed.
Rodriguez and Carson danced a salsa to Bad Bunny during the Super Bowl-themed episode. The judges awarded them 22 out of 40 points: Carrie Ann Inaba gave them 6, Derek Hough 5, Joe Buck 6 and Bruno Tonioli 5. Kimmel said it was Rodriguez’s highest score of the season to that point and noted that the pair was again in the bottom two before elimination.
Kimmel then spoke with the pair backstage. When he asked whether they would accept the result or take legal action, Rodriguez said, “I think we should take legal action,” and Carson agreed. The exchange was presented in a joking tone; the report provides no indication that either had filed a legal challenge. Carson praised Rodriguez and joked that Kimmel could take him back, while Kimmel thanked her for working with him.
DWTS · Week 5 · Reported October 14, 2026
How Guillermo Rodriguez’s Elimination Led to Jimmy Kimmel’s Voter Criticism
Guillermo Rodriguez and Witney Carson left Dancing with the Stars after its Super Bowl-themed episode. Kimmel questioned the result using online video views—but the reported figures do not reveal how voting worked.
& Carson
After the Super Bowl-themed Week 5 episode
Harry Shum Jr. and Jenna Johnson’s prior-week videos
Highest score of Rodriguez’s season to that point, Kimmel said
The backstage legal-action exchange was presented as a joke
Views are not votes
Kimmel pointed to a large gap in YouTube views. Those counts describe video activity, not how many people voted or how votes were distributed.
Prior-week YouTube video views cited on air
The first pair’s videos had just over 3.1 times as many views. The figures do not identify unique viewers, viewer preference across the voting audience, or votes cast.
A salsa, then a 22-point score
Rodriguez and Carson danced salsa to Bad Bunny during the Super Bowl-themed episode. Kimmel noted their score and that they had again been in the bottom two.
Rodriguez & Carson
Inaba
Hough
Buck
Tonioli
Kimmel called it Rodriguez’s highest score of the season up to that point.
The final vote picture
The report does not provide audience vote totals, the complete scoring and voting formula, or a detailed comparison with every contestant.
It also does not establish whether online video views correlated with votes or influenced the elimination.
What Kimmel said—and what it proves
Kimmel challenged the result in his late-night commentary. The reported remarks and clips show his reaction, not evidence that the process was unfair.
Kimmel cited the pair’s video views, their judges’ score, and what he described as broad public support.
He called the judges “radical, left wing.” The account does not show that judges’ politics affected their scoring.
No vote breakdown or process details were reported, so the account cannot establish why the pair was eliminated.
From episode to on-air reaction
The reported timeline links the performance, elimination, and Kimmel’s response without resolving the voting question.
Rodriguez and Carson danced to Bad Bunny on Super Bowl-themed night.
They exited after receiving 22 out of 40 judges’ points.
He cited online views, the score, and support shown in news clips.
The reported details do not explain the final vote calculation.
A joke about legal action
After the elimination, Kimmel spoke with the pair backstage. The exchange was light in tone; no formal challenge was reported.
“I think we should take legal action.”
Guillermo Rodriguez · backstage conversation
Dedication Night was scheduled
The competition was set to continue the following week, with Rodriguez and Carson no longer among the contestants.
When was the next episode?
Dedication Night was scheduled for Tuesday at 8 p.m. ET/PT on ABC and Disney+, with episodes available on Hulu the next day.
What would clarify the result?
Published vote totals and a clear account of how judges’ scores and audience voting contributed to the outcome. Neither was included in the reported details.
Online Attention Was Not the Vote
The episode highlights a distinction between visible online support and the voting that determines a reality-competition result. Kimmel’s chart showed that Rodriguez and Carson’s videos drew substantially more views than the comparison pair’s videos, but those figures do not establish viewer preference across the voting audience. Views may include people who do not vote, and the figures cited do not identify the number of unique viewers or votes.
Kimmel discussed the elimination on his late-night program. His comments were a reaction to the result, not evidence that the show’s process was unfair. The reported details do not provide the vote totals or a breakdown of how judges’ scores and audience voting contributed to the outcome.
Dancing with the Stars salsa dance costume
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Kimmel’s On-Air Comments About Guillermo
Kimmel had publicly supported Rodriguez and Carson during their run on the show. After the elimination, he played clips of news programs in the United States and Canada that had also expressed support for Rodriguez, then discussed the judges’ scores and the final result. He referred to the judges as “radical, left wing” during his commentary; the report does not establish that judges’ politics affected their scoring.
Rodriguez said his goal was to lose weight and told Kimmel he had done so. Carson called him a “sweetheart” and said she would miss working with him. Their elimination ended their participation in the competition. Kimmel’s backstage conversation included a joking exchange about the result.
“Last week, Guillermo and Witney had more than triple the YouTube views of their closest opponent.”
— Jimmy Kimmel, on Jimmy Kimmel Live
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Vote Totals Remain Unreported
The reported account does not give audience vote totals, the full scoring and voting formula, or a detailed explanation of how the pair’s score compared with every other contestant’s. It also does not establish whether online video views correlated with votes. Kimmel’s claim of broad support reflects his commentary and the clips he showed, not a published count of voters.
Rodriguez and Carson’s comments about legal action were made during a light exchange with Kimmel. No filing, formal protest or investigation is reported, so it remains unclear whether the joke would lead to any actual challenge.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Dedication Night Follows the Exit
Dancing with the Stars is scheduled to continue with Dedication Night the following week. The program airs Tuesdays at 8 p.m. ET/PT on ABC and Disney+, with episodes available on Hulu the next day, according to the report. Rodriguez and Carson’s elimination means they are no longer competing in the next episode.
Further information about voting would be needed to assess the gap between online attention and the result; none is included in the details reported so far. The show’s next episode is the immediate scheduled development, while any response from the program about the vote or a possible challenge remains unreported.
Source: Yahoo Entertainment
judge score display for dance competitions
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Key Questions
Who was eliminated from Dancing with the Stars?
Guillermo Rodriguez and Witney Carson were eliminated after the Super Bowl-themed Week 5 episode.
What score did Rodriguez and Carson receive?
The judges gave them 22 out of 40: Inaba scored them 6, Hough 5, Buck 6 and Tonioli 5.
Why did Jimmy Kimmel criticize the result?
Kimmel cited the pair’s YouTube view figures and their score, and questioned why they were eliminated despite what he described as strong support. Those video views are not voting totals.
Did Rodriguez and Carson take legal action?
No legal filing is reported. Rodriguez and Carson agreed when Kimmel jokingly asked if they would take legal action, but the exchange does not establish that they planned a formal challenge.
When is the next Dancing with the Stars episode?
The next episode was scheduled as Dedication Night, airing Tuesday at 8 p.m. ET/PT on ABC and Disney+, with streaming on Hulu the following day.
Source: Yahoo Entertainment
Halloween Picks
halloween
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
